Awesome Jerry! I knew you'd figure this out in short order. Your record on the Prius was most impressive.
Note that there is only about 100 miles of highway driving. Also it should get better once I get it aligned. Right now there is terrible toe-in on the front and one of the backs is toed-out (not as badly as the front is toed in). Why every car isn't aligned at the service centre before delivery is a mystery to me. I can understand why the factory only does "close enough that you can't see it from my house" because the alignment can get knocked out during transport. But delivering an expensive car with poor alignment from a service centre isn't even remotely good.
Obviously speed an temp are huge factors. I'm starting to think that the 19in wheels have a relatively large impact also. Maybe 20-30 Wh/mi average? IS this possible?
Maybe even more. The width of the tread (remember those belts have to bend every time they enter and leave the contact patch area) is a big part of it (along with the other 100 things that change the rolling resistance value of a tire). Temperature is important, but you can mitigate most of that by your charging methodology.
Also, what impact does the 60 vs. 85 have? Factoring out my drive home from Columbus, and numerous spirited test ride/demos I'm realistically at around 290-300 average with the P85 and the 21 inch wheels. I can't imagine 250-260 over 2300 miles.
Thoughts?
Well, I've given quite a few spirited test drives. But I doubt that 60 vs. 85 makes all that much of a difference--unless you floor it every time, then the 60 would always do better in Wh/mile
Having a consistent commuting route where you can learn the terrain so that effective driving becomes automatic is an important factor. I've also found that the Model S wants to go way slower than the Prius, so it's pretty easy to not speed. I actually have to remind myself to speed up in the Model S.
Also road surface makes a difference, so where you live and the roads you drive on are as important as the tires and driving habits.
When it's cool out, having the charging stop just before you drive and having the cabin pre-warmed make a difference too. I've found a/c use doesn't make a great deal of difference although you need to set the fan speed higher than the automatic setting to keep cool.