I selected 3, but I actually wish I had selected 4. My initial tepid response was more a reaction to my test drive compared to the lofty expectations I put on the car based on the reviews and all the wonderful remarks everyone had gushed about the Model S. I was expecting to be blown away and I really wasn't. It was an awesome ride, but just wasn't some mind blowing experience. If a 3 is average, than clearly the Model S is not an average car. It's deserving of a 4. It still needs an improved interior, and still has to be put to the test for longer use, but I can't envision myself getting any other car but the Model S for my next one.