I won't bore everybody with a rehash of my
Taycan test drive, But as impressive as the car was, it was really disappointing in some surprising ways.
Pros:
1) Great build quality, interior materials, and instrument layout and operating system.
2) Porsche cachet value – but partially offset by the VW groups seriously compromised image around the disgraceful dieselgate scandal and the unreliable nature of the Electrify America charging network – As somebody once said VW managed to become the 'anti-Tesla' in that scandal, and all their subsequent talk about electrification and the environment seems disingenuous.
3) Practicality of the Tourismo body Shell.
4) Better handling than prior generation Stock Model S, although I have not driven the new Plaid – But no better handling than a properly tuned Model 3 – Still impressive.
5) Way better thermal management than prior generation Model S but probably no better than Current Plaid
6) Surprisingly good handling and dynamics given its weight . Reminds me of Colin Chapman's aphorism "do your best design and then add lightness." Taycan feels easily 500 pounds lighter than its rather overweight statistic.
Cons:
1) Sticker shock pricing, with a crazy à la carte options list that can add easily 50 to 80 grand to the car – they are the anti-Tesla in relationship to options and pricing. Or as somebody once said why bundle things when you can gouge individually for each item?
2) Severe performance decrement relative to the Plaid which is cheaper, faster and longer range. That's a tough one – especially for folks who once could argue that yes the Taycan is more expensive but it's got a little bit more performance and a lot more build quality. One of those checkboxes is now gone.
3) Surprising nonlinearities in relationship to accelerator and torque delivery, especially when going from full throttle to trailing throttle. It's nothing less than abrupt and jerky, and in that sense it's much harder to drive smoothly if you're trying to drive really fast. This was shocking but it was very discernible. The dealer confirmed that this was not an aberration on my particular Turbo S model.
4) Inability to configure regen breaking to more than 0.1 G default. This is just baffling and frankly unacceptable. The first 0.3-0.4 G's of braking achieved when pressing on the friction brakes are regen. Why Porsche chose to lock in users to an old meme instead of transitioning to the much more practical and safer use of heavier regen is just this side of bizarre, and makes you ask the same question here as you do around the diesel gate scandal – namely what are they smoking?! One pedal driving is simply not possible. Hopefully Porsche will wake up and reconfigure this in a future software update. Speaking of which, are they still forcing you to bring the car in to the dealer to get a software update? Seriously?
5) Weight. Heavier than old generation Model S and now ~300 pounds heavier than plaid.
6) Interior space including trunk space but also backseat for the size of the car is really disappointing. This is the cost of a legacy chassis design crossed over into an EV. Tesla started with a clean sheet of paper clearly has much better space utilization, especially in the model 3 and model Y, but also in the model S.
7) Value. Just can't see how the Taycan is any kind of good value in view of the plaid or the Model 3. You can get a Model 3 Performance, install aftermarket wheels and tires and the MPP suspension kit and still come in under 60,000 bucks. You can't get anything in Porsche for 60,000 bucks new.
8) Electrify America network versus Supercharging network. Sorry that's still just not even close And don't tell me about the theoretical advantages of the 350 kW charging and the 800 V architecture. Good luck doing an actual road trip where any of that is meaningful compared to how many EA charging stalls are dead.
Brand loyalty is very tribal so I'm sure people who are very loyal to Porsche will hear all this as a slam. It's not. It's simply a statement of where the brands sit right now in terms of what they're offering for your dollar.
I really enjoyed the Taycan when I had it but I would not trade it dollar for dollar for the Model 3 Performance. Or for that matter for a new Plaid Even up.