Is this different than it was before?
Yes. I specifically bought the car only because the prepaid "Unlimited Ranger 4+4" service was available. At the time "$100 flat fee" Ranger service was also an option. Earlier, "$1/mile" Ranger service was promised. Tesla was aggressively marketing the Ranger service.
Tesla would have zero sales in upstate NY if they hadn't offered all of this! In fact, there are dozens of Teslas in upstate NY, but recent buyers don't know what sort of hell they may have bought into. And they're going to turn on the company when they find out, especially if the drivetrain replacements contineu to be a problem...
I've always cautioned people AWAY from buying this car if they are more than 50 miles from a service center. I don't know any other car company that offers free transportation for warranty service if the car is 200 miles from a dealership. I'm not familiar with Tesla's policy here, which is why I'm asking.
The difference is that for most car companies, you can never get 200 miles from a dealership without going very deep into the middle of nowhere. For Tesla, over 200 miles from a Service Center still includes places like Pittsburgh.
If they're not going to offer service at less than astronomical prices (and "staying overnight in a hotel in order to drop the car off" is an astronomical price, too), they need to stop selling cars into these markets. Which would be a pretty poor decision.
I think Elon may have grossly underestimated the capital necessary to deploy a proper network of Service Centers, but still, that's not an excuse.
- - - Updated - - -
I guess what I'm trying to say is it's not a situation where, at least in my mind, a lot of the option 3 people are selecting option 3 because of, say, an engineering problem, like, for example, the one that exists (or existed) with the early contactors and / or the 12V batteries. I can see problems like that being very hard to solve, and costly to get to the bottom of, and I think, for the most part, we all can, and we're willing to cut Tesla slack on those kinds of things, for all the reasons the supporters give for supporting Tesla. But the communications problems cost next to nothing to fix.
Well, some of them are expensive to fix, but even the cheap ones are not being solved. Software engineering remains a black hole out of which infomration does not come, not even to the service centers. And problems which seemed to have been fixed have been broken again, as we have seen with inconsistent messaging repeatedly.
I'm not going to say that this communications stuff is *easy* to solve, because it requires the right sort of competent manager. I am going to say that Tesla obviously doesn't have enough of that sort of manager.
I agree that (as someone picking option 3), I still feel just as positive about the CAR -- the engineering remains great -- but I'm feeling less and less positive about the COMPANY.