Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

ARENA/NRMA national fast charging network

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Resistance is not fixed. And charging current does not stay the same - the charging rate actually reduces as SoC increases
The internal resistance of lithium ion batteries is fairly flat throughout the charge cycle.
In this context P=VI is a more suitable equation. For the same Power 800V architecture cars require half the current vs 400V cars. Also, as pack voltage increases, power increases for the same current (if charger is maxed out). Chargers will be generally current limited for Teslas.
Also a good equation, but it resolves a different variable (power rather than voltage).
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Quickst
Anyone know who makes these 22kW DC chargers?

230V 3 phase 32A input , DC CCS2 out

Photo from Plugshare
A few of these outback places seem to have similar units.

IMG_1378.jpeg
 
Surely NRMA could at least release some renders or actual detail.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: Vostok
Surely NRMA could at least release some renders or actual detail.

I once did a back-of-the envelope calculation as to what it would take to build a completely off-grid 2 x 175 kW DCFC. You’d need about 1200 solar panels and two Tesla Megapacks, total cost around $3M. If you could sell that electricity at $1/kWh (not unreasonable in the middle of nowhere) you’d need 15-20 cars per day buying 50 kWh each just to break even in 10 years, let alone make a profit, assuming no financing or other operational costs (e.g. maintenance, land leases, backend costs etc). It’s doable with Government funding covering part of the capex, but a very tough gig.
 
I once did a back-of-the envelope calculation as to what it would take to build a completely off-grid 2 x 175 kW DCFC. You’d need about 1200 solar panels and two Tesla Megapacks, total cost around $3M. If you could sell that electricity at $1/kWh (not unreasonable in the middle of nowhere) you’d need 15-20 cars per day buying 50 kWh each just to break even in 10 years, let alone make a profit, assuming no financing or other operational costs (e.g. maintenance, land leases, backend costs etc). It’s doable with Government funding covering part of the capex, but a very tough gig.
There are a couple of other variables here:

- If they build at (e.g.) a roadhouse site, that roadhouse probably runs off a diesel generator now. The same solar/battery setup could be used to replace the diesel on site there. So that's another possible consumer of the energy (although I can't imagine the total energy used is going to be a lot compared to 15-20 cars per day charging)

- In NRMA's case, across 117 sites they can use the revenue from their busier sites to offset their less busy sites. Or at the moment it's probably more accurate to say they use the revenue from the other parts of their business to offset all of their EV charging sites, but this will change.

I'm also curious to see what happens when NRMA sites overlap with others. At Broome or Port Hedland for example, the towns are big enough that it probably makes sense for there to be two different fast charging sites in different locations. But when both NRMA and the WA EV Network plan to install at the Billabong Roadhouse … there's nothing but the roadhouse for hundreds of kilometres in each direction, and both networks have said they're planning to build a solar/battery setup to accompany their off-grid fast charger sites. Are there really going to be two completely independent solar/battery systems at each of these off-grid roadhouses?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vostok
I once did a back-of-the envelope calculation as to what it would take to build a completely off-grid 2 x 175 kW DCFC. You’d need about 1200 solar panels and two Tesla Megapacks, total cost around $3M. If you could sell that electricity at $1/kWh (not unreasonable in the middle of nowhere) you’d need 15-20 cars per day buying 50 kWh each just to break even in 10 years, let alone make a profit, assuming no financing or other operational costs (e.g. maintenance, land leases, backend costs etc). It’s doable with Government funding covering part of the capex, but a very tough gig.
A lot of the proposed locations are still in populated localities with limited and costly generator power. I think the government should be looking at using this as an opportunity to provide green energy solutions in remote locations. This may even save these locations some money and have a better return on investment. There is some state overlap here as some locations will have a state run and subsidised microgrid(I guess nowadays maybe private energy distributor but still state subsidised).
 
Cars per day won't be a problem on the main highways. This data from Mainroads WA taken at Eucla on the Eyre Highway shows around 600 vehicles per day (half of which are trucks):
https://reportingcentreresources.mainroads.wa.gov.au/public/data/traffic_map/CS/Hourly Volume.52123.2023.pdf

However if all 300 of those passenger vehicles per day were EVs, you’d need more than 2x175 kW DCFCs to support them. The whole solution would need to be scaled, and while there would be some efficiencies as the site got larger (Erlang tables) the underlying economics of how many cars per station per day you needed for the numbers to stack up might not improve much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: johnchidgey
Anyone know who makes these 22kW DC chargers?

230V 3 phase 32A input , DC CCS2 out

Photo from Plugshare
A few of these outback places seem to have similar units.

View attachment 973477
That’s been in place at Balladonia for nearly two years and has proven to be reliable despite the occasional time charging needs to be restarted There is a lower cost and less bulky brand with the same output that a few drivers have been using as portable units that also appears to have so far proven to be reliable.
 
Depends which part of the App. Only paid chargers appear in the “EV Chargers.. Find, Charge, Pay” part of the App, but all chargers appear in the “Near Me… EV Chargers” part of the App. Obvious, innit 🙄
The South Australian RAA App is a bit awkward too. Its like they have put a window inside a window and scrolling around it is not very intuitive. You can move the map around around with one finger to a certain zoom level, then you have to use two otherwise the whole page moves around, then you zoom out and it resets to the highest zoom level.. Plugshare is a heaps better interface.
 
  • Like
Reactions: B3AU