I don't want hypothetical, I'm wanting you to back your position.
I believe that most battery experts would disagree with your statement "If you want the longest life out of your battery charge..."
The numbers that you are quoting seem to be around battery degradation numbers, not longevity, there is a difference.
And the battery degradation numbers are relatively insignificant, a few percent difference on average.
The number of cycles and age of the battery are probably much bigger players in the longevity of the battery.
But the big thing is, for Model 3 and Model Y even after 6 years, longevity hasn't become a blip on the radar yet.