Your pics are basically thumbnails and aren't legible.
If it's a screen shot of reviews, I can tell you with 100% certainty that any and all reviews found on tire sites are complete BS. At best, their "winter" category is being rated by a ton of people living in California who never experience even close to a true winter. Without proper consideration for the region in which the tires will be used, these global ratings are about as worthless as can be. I found this out the hard way.
I compared the crap out of them before buying my last non-DWS tire. All of which basically put the Michelin Pilot Sport A/S 3+ ahead of the DWS 06+ in terms of winter handling specifically. Since the tire was nearly 2x more than the DWS I decide that it would be worth the premium to get a tire that was slightly better than my tried and true DWS.
Man, those tires were squirrelly and scary in anything below typical temperatures. Not even talking the subzero temps we're experiencing currently but even anything approaching freezing temps which is far more common. I'm pretty sure they use the same compound from their Pilot Sports and then just cut less aggressive tread patterns for their A/S version.
In my experience, the compound lost it's grip and became hard af making it seem like marbles on glass, even if there wasn't any snow. This cause for a super sketchy trip across I40 in New Mexico where it wasn't even snowy but the cold temps and crappy tire compound made it feel like it was sheet ice on the surface. I've been driving in the Midwest for decades and that was one of the sketchiest experiences. I still can't believe there wasn't even snow on the ground.
I couldn't get those tires off of my car fast enough after that experience. Never again.
