Looking for the best looking mats
I went with Tesmanian mainly due to price and side lip coverage (also, at the time of my ordering, Maxpiders were close, but not yet shipping orders.
I live in a snow-heavy area so I wanted ones that were
1. simple, sturdy, easy to clean
2. provided ample side coverage for both front driver/passenger and back passenger.
I particularly liked how high the lip goes up for the single-piece back passenger mat - comparatively to the Maxpiders, I feel like Tesmanians are higher and provide slightly better snow/water protection. If I lived in Cali or somewhere w/o snow and didn't mind the extra $$ for maxpiders, I do think those look & rate very well.