Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Russia/Ukraine conflict

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Pulling the various reports together I've seen suggests the following (in the border area above Kharkiv):
1. There aren't enough Russian troops to capture a large city like Kharkiv, but it's one of their targets currently.
2. Kharkiv isn't within artillery range so they need to create a 'buffer zone' in order to make that happen so they can pound the city to destruction in the normal way.
3. The Russians are using 'golfcarts' and motorbikes in areas to insert many small assault groups of poorly trained troops to overwhelm UKR defences. This is why the heavy vehicle losses have dropped but troop casualties are at a peak.
4. UKR do a very good job of taking out large assualt groups backed up by tanks/APCs using drones/HIMARS/Bradleys/ATGMs etc. These small, fast insertion groups spread over a wider area present a smaller, more dispersed target.
5. UKR need a lot more drones (with operators) and explosives to manufacture specific drone-based ordanance to counter that type of threat. HIMARS/ATACMS and other precision artillery will be wasted on small assault groups like that, so they aren't using them as they would on large, mechanized groups. This is possibly why RUS is able to slowly move forward and create the buffer zone, albeit with very heavy losses of men.
6. RUS are using this tactic now because they can't wait until they have enough manpower/equipment to attack in much larger mechanised groups due to the threat of the impending arrival of U.S. weapons.

If they're allowed to continue in this way and create the buffer zone, they'll move artillery in and start pounding Kharkiv to rubble. It's not going to be a quick or easy process and as long as UKR can get what they need in the meantime I think they should be able to push them back out of this buffer zone and stabilize that part of the front. So it's yet again down to U.S. and EU delivering what's needed in a timely manner. The money is being committed but the delivery seem to be very slow.

Anyway, still some good work being done using what they have right now. Big strike on Belbek airfield last night:

 
Last edited:
Pulling the various reports together I've seen suggests the following (in the border area above Kharkiv):
1. There aren't enough Russian troops to capture a large city like Kharkiv, but it's one of their targets currently.
2. Kharkiv isn't within artillery range so they need to create a 'buffer zone' in order to make that happen so they can pound the city to destruction in the normal way.
3. The Russians are using 'golfcarts' and motorbikes in areas to insert many small assault groups of poorly trained troops to overwhelm UKR defences. This is why the heavy vehicle losses have dropped but troop casualties are at a peak.
4. UKR do a very good job of taking out large assualt groups backed up by tanks/APCs using drones/HIMARS/Bradleys/ATGMs etc. These small, fast insertion groups spread over a wider area present a smaller, more dispersed target.
5. UKR need a lot more drones (with operators) and explosives to manufacture specific drone-based ordanance to counter that type of threat. HIMARS/ATACMS and other precision artillery will be wasted on small assault groups like that, so they aren't using them as they would on large, mechanized groups. This is possibly why RUS is able to slowly move forward and create the buffer zone, albeit with very heavy losses of men.
6. RUS are using this tactic now because they can't wait until they have enough manpower/equipment to attack in much larger mechanised groups due to the threat of the impending arrival of U.S. weapons.

If they're allowed to continue in this way and create the buffer zone, they'll move artillery in and start pounding Kharkiv to rubble. It's not going to be a quick or easy process and as long as UKR can get what they need in the meantime I think they should be able to push them back out of this buffer zone and stabilize that part of the front. So it's yet again down to U.S. and EU delivering what's needed in a timely manner. The money is being committed but the delivery seem to be very slow.

Anyway, still some good work being done using what they have right now. Big strike on Belbek airfield last night:


You may be right. Instead of ATACMS, small groups of infantry are a good target for 155mm cluster munitions. The US has a lot of it and has pretty much decided not to use it again. It should all be shipped to Ukraine for just this sort of combat. The Ukrainians got a small amount of the stuff last year and it helped them a lot.
 
You may be right. Instead of ATACMS, small groups of infantry are a good target for 155mm cluster munitions. The US has a lot of it and has pretty much decided not to use it again. It should all be shipped to Ukraine for just this sort of combat. The Ukrainians got a small amount of the stuff last year and it helped them a lot.
This is the sort of thing I'm hoping is going to turn up soon. In some respects, it might be better to tactically withdraw from some areas to let the surviving assault groups form into larger holding positions, then hit those with artillery, mortars and the larger kamikazee drones we've recently seen which are capable of demolishing whole buildings rather than just hitting one or two troops.

The other aspect not helping is the supposed insistance of not allowing UKR to go after targets on RUS territory. Having to wait until they cross the border before engaging gives them a massive head start. Maybe that's softening though, as in the Blinken-Kuleba briefing today this was reported: "When asked whether the US prohibits Ukraine from using its own weapons to strike Russia, Blinken responded that Washington “does not encourage this, but Ukraine must decide for itself what to do.”

I've noticed the media are already spreading doom and gloom because of these advances from the border. I don't think it's as bad as they make out, but some action in the opposite direction would go down really well and keep morale up. UKR have pushed them out from there once and they can do it again.
 
Last edited:
Here is a run of the mill analysis of the situation and it’s ramifications ...
Nothing new....except....one throw away line from Putin’s speech....(my) ‘family is learning Mandarin’
Perhaps an exit strategy ?
 
Kharkiv battle update. Doesn't sound good.

Haven't watched that vid. But that channel seem to have had quite the 'mixed' record previously...

Today according to the DeepStateMap there is no movement on the Kharkiv front. There is unfortunately though movement in the Vovchansk direction.

 
From today’s Guardian

  • The US is considering sending an extra Patriot air defence battery to Ukraine, according to Bloomberg. It comes after the US secretary of state, Antony Blinken, arrived in Kyiv on Tuesday on his first visit to Ukraine since a major US aid package was passed last month. Blinken, who arrived by train from Poland in an unannounced visit, met with Ukraine’s president, Volodymyr Zelenskiy. “Some of it has already arrived and more of it will be arriving,” said Blinken of the US aid. “And that’s going to make a real difference against the ongoing Russian aggression on the battlefield.”

  • Russia has put its Bulava intercontinental ballistic missile into service, the Tass state news agency reported on Tuesday, citing the system’s chief designer.

  • Ukrainian grid operator Ukrenergo said on Tuesday that power shortages caused by damage from Russian strikes had prompted controlled countrywide cuts from 9pm to midnight. “The reason is a significant shortage of electricity in the system as a result of Russian shelling as well as increased consumption because of cold weather,” Ukrenergo said.


Not specific to Ukraine, but perhaps linked (?)

Slovakia's prime minister in life-threatening condition: office​

Robert Fico is in a life-threatening condition, the Slovak government office said in an emailed statement, Reuters reported.


…and…

 
Putin has effectively just put the whole military industrial complex under presidential control, thereby boosting his personal power by taking over the whole of the war economy and the opportunities for corruption that go with it.

In the short term this makes Putin seem even more impregnable and underlines the fact that he is not interested in any kind of peace that would put a stop to the war, which feeds his power, political and material. It also shows how wary he is of political challengers, and leaves him very vulnerable should the war not go his way. In the medium and long term, this will spell disaster for the Russian economy, as the war drains resources and human power into a cycle of production whose only aim is to feed the war.

Those who think that Putin would be open to negotiating over a piece of eastern Ukraine and Crimea should bear this in mind when hoping for a quick negotiated end to this war. Putin needs war to survive.

 
Pulling the various reports together I've seen suggests the following (in the border area above Kharkiv):
1. There aren't enough Russian troops to capture a large city like Kharkiv, but it's one of their targets currently.
2. Kharkiv isn't within artillery range so they need to create a 'buffer zone' in order to make that happen so they can pound the city to destruction in the normal way.
3. The Russians are using 'golfcarts' and motorbikes in areas to insert many small assault groups of poorly trained troops to overwhelm UKR defences. This is why the heavy vehicle losses have dropped but troop casualties are at a peak.
4. UKR do a very good job of taking out large assualt groups backed up by tanks/APCs using drones/HIMARS/Bradleys/ATGMs etc. These small, fast insertion groups spread over a wider area present a smaller, more dispersed target.
5. UKR need a lot more drones (with operators) and explosives to manufacture specific drone-based ordanance to counter that type of threat. HIMARS/ATACMS and other precision artillery will be wasted on small assault groups like that, so they aren't using them as they would on large, mechanized groups. This is possibly why RUS is able to slowly move forward and create the buffer zone, albeit with very heavy losses of men.
6. RUS are using this tactic now because they can't wait until they have enough manpower/equipment to attack in much larger mechanised groups due to the threat of the impending arrival of U.S. weapons.

If they're allowed to continue in this way and create the buffer zone, they'll move artillery in and start pounding Kharkiv to rubble. It's not going to be a quick or easy process and as long as UKR can get what they need in the meantime I think they should be able to push them back out of this buffer zone and stabilize that part of the front. So it's yet again down to U.S. and EU delivering what's needed in a timely manner. The money is being committed but the delivery seem to be very slow.

Anyway, still some good work being done using what they have right now. Big strike on Belbek airfield last night:

Yep, Ruzzia is returning these precious lands to the Motherland by crushing everything to good Ruzzian dust. Just like the good old days. Apparently nothing changes ever in Ruzzia. Long Live Tzar Vlady the Murderer.
 
From today’s Guardian








Not specific to Ukraine, but perhaps linked (?)




…and…


Robert Fico (PM of Slovakia) is very pro-Russia, so the Russians wouldn't be behind an assassination attempt of him. And the west doesn't tend to do physical assassinations. We will learn more as police investigate, but it may have been a loner who didn't like Fico.
 
Robert Fico (PM of Slovakia) is very pro-Russia, so the Russians wouldn't be behind an assassination attempt of him. And the west doesn't tend to do physical assassinations. We will learn more as police investigate, but it may have been a loner who didn't like Fico.

I saw someone link to a news article on twitter that implied that his pro Russian stance wasn't quite as strong as it seemed and that he was on the verge of turning on them.

Hardly proof of Russian involvement but its interesting.

Then again going more conspiracy brained on this I might say that Russia had a pro Russian PM assassinated as a way to cause chaos in Slovakia without implicating themselves.
 
IMG_2186.jpeg
 
I saw someone link to a news article on twitter that implied that his pro Russian stance wasn't quite as strong as it seemed and that he was on the verge of turning on them.

Hardly proof of Russian involvement but its interesting.

Then again going more conspiracy brained on this I might say that Russia had a pro Russian PM assassinated as a way to cause chaos in Slovakia without implicating themselves.
I hope it's correct that his pro Russian stance is softening. However he ran on a platform of no slovak government money to support Ukraine. He is, due to Slovakia's government system, a minority PM. There are many many Slovakians who support Ukraine.


He pooh-poohed this drive when it started as symbolic only. It hugely over performed.
 

Russian Forces Abduct and Execute Ukrainian Civilians in Vovchansk Amid Evacuations

MAY 16, 2024 13:36

In the northern part of Vovchansk, currently an active combat zone, Russian military personnel are taking civilians captive, according to Ukrainian Minister of Internal Affairs Ihor Klymenko. [...]

Russian forces attempting to gain a foothold in the city have prevented evacuations by abducting residents and forcing them into basements.

There are reports of the first civilian executions by Russian forces. In one instance, a Vovchansk resident attempting to escape on foot was killed by Russian troops for refusing to follow their orders.

Previously, local authorities in Vovchansk reported two missing volunteers, suspected of being killed by Russian troops.


 
Two of the Russian Dictator's Mig-31K Cruise Missile Carriers have allegedly been promoted to scrap.

Satellite images show the results of the ATACMS attack on Belbek Air Base in occupied Crimea. Two Mig-31K and an ammuniton warehouse destroyed.

twitter.com/NOELreports/status/1791187282612887719