Thanks. So my question is would it make sense for Tesla to save this valuation allowance until the tax rate has been hiked as opposed to right away? Some of us are expecting a huge profit at some point this year.
This requires a complicated answer but I will try to keep it non-technical for the non-accountants here. (The Deferred Tax topic is complicated to explain)
Tesla could take $1.9B now as a benefit and then another $0.5B later if the tax rate increases.
However, it would likely go as follows:
If Biden wins the election and gets a new tax policy through Congress, it would likely not be effective until Jan 2022.
Telsa will likely use up a portion of this tax asset in 2021 reducing the $1.9B down to about $1.3B.
So by the time the asset gets revalued from a 21% to 28% tax rate, it is no longer at $1.9B but around $1.3B.
Ok - maybe I will make it a bit more complicated.
- Since 2004, Tesla has lost $6.9B.
- That means Tesla does not need to pay taxes on future profit of $6.9B
- At a tax rate of 28% (21% federal and 7% state), this is a $1.9B Tax Benefit/Asset ($6.9B x 28% = $1.9B)
- Let's assume they have $2B in pre-tax profit in 2021. Tesla will use a portion of the $6.9m prior losses to pay no tax.
- In 2022, the losses to offset future income is now only $4.9B ($6.9B loss less 2021 income of $2.0B)
- If Federal Taxes change to 28% then total tax rate is 35% (with 7% state).
- Tax asset will now be $1.7B ($4.9B x 35%)