anticitizen13.7
Not posting at TMC after 9/17/2018
What is incorrect? The fact that a 2010 Mercedes E-Class has a stronger roof than a Model S and Tesla still claimed in 2013 that the Model S roof is so exceptionally strong that it broke the machine? Regardless, Musk's claim was made in reference to the 4x strength to weight ratio.
2010 Mercedes E-Class
Peak force 20,961 lbs
Strength-to-weight ratio 5.40
2016 Tesla Model S
Peak force 19,271 lbs
Strength-to-weight ratio 4.33
The huge list you posted includes the Honda Fit, for example.
Roof force peak is about 12,900 lbs., less than the Model S.
In absolute terms the Fit has a weaker roof in this test than Model S. only in ratio of force to weight is it superior.