I just picked up a 23 MYP in March. I was holding off because previous year Teslas I’d rented drove like crap (compared to my Acura at the time). But, I finally caved and bought one for 23. My first impressions were, “WOW I love this car!”
I’ve now put 2500 miles on it, and I can definitely say, the ride is fantastic! I drive mine in sport mode and always keep the suspension stiff. But here’s the other thing… I travel. A lot. And when I do, I rent cars. Maybe 50 a year. I can say that many of the complaints I hear on this forum about the MYP can be found in every other car. I’ve rented Audis, Maseratis, BMWs, Acuras..: and every time, when I get back to my MYP, I’ve found it to be superior in noise and ride quality.
I rented BMW M Sport today. While a fun car to drive, the suspension was loud. The steering was loose. The car felt, off. Now, I’m sure if I drove it every day I might feel different. But, I don’t. And at the end of each trip, I look forward to getting back into the quiet cabin of my MYP.
So, comfort is in the eye of the beholder. We know that. I drive enough cars that I feel comfortable saying my experience has allowed me to rise above bias. I still love to drive lots of cars. But I look forward to driving my MYP the most. 2023 made a huge difference. I won’t even rent 2022 MYs. They're great cars, but the new suspension did it for me.