Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Extended Warranty claims

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
My brother sold cars for 20 years before getting moved into the finance office - where they sell the extended warranties. He said experience has taught him that they aren't worth it - that if you put the money in an investment account it will make you money and you probably won't ever touch that dough.

CAVEAT: He almost never worked with EV's.

Common issue: Third party companies exclude a lot of parts - you MUST read what's covered and what's not. Bumper to bumper coverage is VERY expensive. If it's not, be wary.

Another common issue: the company collects a ton of money and files for bankruptcy. You MUST find out if the company you're considering has a real escrow account - not a phony one.
It's a progression. Up till - early 80s cars in general not reliable and require costly repairs frequently, then the Japanese brands introduce reliable cars and the competition forces other brands to improve reliability, service contracts and warranties become a profit center of car dealership. Eventually most cars are reliable until 80-90k and not requiring major repairs, most people won't buy extended warranty as they know that's a big margin for the dealer and warranty companies, also lease becoming common, making it moot to buy it. I still remembered a finance manager begging me to buy it to make the quotas and told me to cancel it the week after for a full refund.

Now we are in the EVs era. Proprietary parts, cannot be fixed in anywhere else other than the dealer or manufacturer, expensive disposable parts. Early MS handle is 1k a piece, MCU is 4K, even today headlights are 3500 OTD and the DRL always burn quickly and unevenly.

The DRU, battery are astronomical priced to replace after the factory warranty. Slowly we see few other shops can fix EV, sometimes using salvaged parts, some parts becoming serviceable and more reliable after multiple revisions. I switched to EV 10 years ago and all said battery price will come down, EV has less parts to break down. I think there are some truth to it in manufacturing but replacing the whole battery pack is still very expensive to the consumer, for other parts they will break down and I can see the same reliability progress as the ICE car.
 
  • Like
Reactions: YBosy
For the record, for my Ford Escape hybrid I bought an extended warranty because I was well aware some parts were fairly expensive and I had no experience with them, for example the item which changes braking from regen to pressure in order to stop forward motion is a $1,500 part.

I was very well aware this purchase was mostly for peace of mind, and I feel I absolutely go my money's worth!

When I went to renew it, the Ford dealer service manager made a face and recommended against the purchase. "We never see those in for repair" he said. Probably true, but the insurance made me feel good. YMMV.

As the OP stated, perhaps a claim could have resulted in a different experience. I will almost certainly extend my MYP when the time comes.