Just a heads up, I sold my wheels and tires with 46 miles on them for $2600 + $300 shipping. Total of $2900.
Brand new take-off wheels and tires with low mileage are going for around $2500.
A new set of Michelin Pilot Sport 4S tires costs $1320 (before mounting and balancing). Warranty on those is 30,000 miles. Since you have 5,000 miles on yours, I'd say the tires have lost about $1320×(5000/30000)=$220 in value.
So, a fair asking price, assuming perfect condition, would be $2200 to $2300.
Hope that helps.