Welcome to Tesla Motors Club
Discuss Tesla's Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y, Cybertruck, Roadster and More.
Register

Hydrocarbons, Industrial Metals and the Alternative Energy Fallacy

This site may earn commission on affiliate links.
Someone on Seeking Alpha trying to compare Hydrocarbon production to battery production, among other things:

Hydrocarbons, Industrial Metals and the Alternative Energy Fallacy

I'm a relentless critic of vehicle electrification schemes like Tesla Motors (TSLA) because they're the most egregious offenders and doomed to fail when EV hype goes careening off the industrial metals cliff at 120 mph. Let's get real here. Tesla carries a market capitalization of $2.8 billion and has a net worth of less than $400 million, so its stock price is 86% air – a bubble in search of a pin. Tesla plans to become a global leader in the development of new electric drive technologies that will use immense amounts of industrial metals to conserve irrelevant amounts of hydrocarbons. Even if Tesla achieves its lofty technological goals it must fail as a business. Investors who chase the EV dream without considering the natural resource realities are doomed to suffer immense losses. Tesla can't possibly succeed. Its fair market value is zero. The stock is a perfect short.
 
He's blasting the article across just about all the financial web sites this weekend. What's dangerous is that he mixes in a populist recycle mantra, making people think he really cares about the environment. Unfortunately, stories like this provide fodder for people looking for rationalizations to maintain the status-quo. I'm sure the "replacing Middle Eastern oil with South American Lithium" argument will come up again and again for a while.